''The Downfall''

[Montana]

nope no sense at all, so yeah random question is Heather the girl Amy gets to ride Sundance? If yes does she till ride Sundance?

[Cem]

This is a stupidly complicated question to answer.

Heather is Ty's new girlfriend. Her and her family just moved in to the area and (I think) he met her when he was out riding one day. Anyway, ,they started seeing each other and fro some bizzare reason Ty has her riding Sundance for him. But Heather doesn't have much riding experence so this makes no sense cause we all know Sundance is a tricky horse!

Yes Amy still rides Sunny when she's home though.

What I never understood though, is why Amy never got upset with Ty for having his new girl ride Sunny for her. I mean she's always been a little posesive, paticularly when it comes to Sundance and Spindleberry, but she never made a single fuss about this.

So none of it makes any sense!

And is yet another thing I really, really hate.

[Montana]

I know thats what I thought. If you ask me thats just not human, not being bothered about your ex's new girlfriend riding YOUR pony. maybe Im just possesive like that but....

I remeber my friend said something to me about somebodys girlfriend riding my pony I was like she comes near my pony I will (well you can guess XD)

I mean she wasnt a very nice girl anyway, more like a spoilt rich brat.

[Cem]

I know! Totally nuts that Amy didn't mind her riding Sunny. Espessially seeing how close Amy and Ty were!

[xoxLBROXxox]

OK, for my opinion on these special editions and the sudden change in Amy / the storyline etc.

Good Stuff: Well, actually, I think it's quite exciting. It's making me really curious. The books are very interesting in my opinion.

Bad Stuff: Yeah, Amy has changed and Ty has changed and I wish they were together! They're made for eachother!

But I am still determined they will get back together. I mean, it would be cruelty if they didn't in the end. They have such a history and everything. I still believe it's going to have a happy ending so I'm going to keep on reading!  But I'm confused about the order... Is book 21 where she decides to go to college? Then what is the first Special Edition? I've read Beyond the Horizon, I don't know where that comes.. Where does A Winter's Gift fit in and where does a summer to remember fit in??

[Cem]

There are 20 numbered books, and 4 special editions. Book 19 is where she decides she's going to go to college, the second special edition is the first one with her at college, and thats Beyond the Horizon.

The first special edition is Holiday Memories (Winter Memories in the UK) and that comes around book 18.

The second SE is Beyond the Horizon, and that comes after book #20 Always There. Then its A Winters Gift, then A Summer to Remember.

[xoxLBROXxox]

Ohhh thanks Cem! That means I need to read A Winter's Gift next, then A Summer To Remember. Thanks this was helpful x

[Cem]

Cool, glad. I have to say renaming Holiday Memories, Winter Memories in the UK then releasing a book titled A Winter Gift is just asking for confusion!! That and having the same book with two titles lol

[Heather]

you guys are right, the characters have changed too much it makes me cry to think of what happened to ty and amy. and amy is just totally changing she just is turning so different it makes me sad to watch the real her disapear.

 i dont like the book B.t.H

 all of the special editions change amy from who she really was and now she is totally different....but i am gonna keep reading.